Google Business Profile vs a website for trades

Lead sources23 August 20267 min read

Short answer: they are different tools for different halves of one journey. The Business Profile wins the map listing and the reviews; the website answers every question a customer has before deciding to ring you. Firms that win local searches almost always run both — the profile is the signpost, the website is where the signpost points.

What the profile genuinely does

A Google Business Profile is free to set up and run, and it puts your firm on Google Maps and into local results for your category and area. It shows your opening hours, your phone number and — critically — your reviews, which for many customers is the first credibility check there is. For a trade business with no other web presence at all, setting up the profile is the single highest-value hour available. Nothing in this article argues otherwise. One caveat earned the hard way by many firms: Google’s verification process can take longer than expected, so start it early rather than the week you need the listing live.

Where it stops

• It cannot answer questions. A profile holds a category, a phone number and a few photographs. It cannot explain the difference between a putlog and an independent scaffold, what a boiler swap involves, or why your quote is shaped the way it is. Customers who check before ringing — most of them, these days — run out of answers quickly.
• It cannot take enquiries. There is no enquiry form, no quote request, no way for a customer to describe their job at 11pm beyond ringing and hoping someone answers.
• It cannot show work properly. A photo grid is not a project gallery. Accreditations get a line, not a page with numbers and scope.
• It cannot be extended. A profile is one pin with one category and one service radius. It cannot grow a page per town, answer a question about temporary roof hire, or cover the firm that works three counties wide. The long tail — “scaffolder for a chimney stack in Ashford”, “how much does a temporary roof cost” — belongs to pages, because pages are what can actually answer those questions.
• It lives on Google’s terms. Categories, features and eligibility change when Google changes them, as firms who have had profiles suspended mid-dispute will confirm. Free does not mean owned.

How the two actually work together

Watch the journey of a typical customer: a recommendation arrives, or the name is seen on a van. They type the name into Google. The profile appears, with its review count — good. Then comes the decision moment, and this is where firms divide. If clicking through lands on nothing, or on a Facebook page last updated after a job two summers ago, the customer guesses. If it lands on a site that states services, areas, insurance and how quoting works, the guess becomes a decision. Same profile, same reviews — completely different outcome.

When the profile alone is enough

Honesty requires the counter-case. A sole trader doing reactive work in one postcode — burst pipes, emergency call-outs — whose diary is already full from Maps calls and repeat customers may genuinely not need more. The profile covers discovery; the phone covers conversion; done. The risk is not today’s diary, it is the quiet quarter, the want to raise rates, or the day Google adjusts something — at which point having never built the owned half means starting from zero while competitors do not have to.

Choose each when

• Profile alone suits: single-postcode reactive trades, diaries full from Maps and repeats, no capacity or appetite for more.
• Both together suit: anyone who wants the phone to ring with better qualified jobs, needs to be found beyond their own name, or plans to still be trading in five years.

Next

The social-media cousin of this question is covered in Facebook page vs a website, and how the paid platforms compare against owning the channel is in what a lead really costs. The general principles sit in the main guide to trade websites.

Questions people also ask